real-estate · 16 min read · Updated August 17, 2026

92% of Agents Give Up on Expireds After the First Week

The median gross income for real estate agents with two years or less of experience was just $14,100 in 2022. Many agents struggle to generate consistent listing inventory.

The median gross income for real estate agents with two years or less of experience was just $14,100 in 2022. Many agents struggle to generate consistent listing inventory. Expired listings offer a direct path to homeowners who have already indicated a desire to sell. This article provides actionable expired listing scripts and strategies. We will cover the critical timing for calls, effective opening lines, and how to navigate common seller objections. You will learn the math behind converting dials into listing appointments. We also address the legalities of cold calling expireds and how to acquire these leads. Our focus is on practical, real-world application for US listing agents and team leads.

92% of Agents Give Up on Expireds After the First Week

Expired listings are a race. In the first 24 hours, sellers get 20 to 50 calls. Most agents blitz the phones on Day 1. They use dialers like Mojo Dialer or REDX. They focus on the initial contact. This high volume of early calls often overwhelms sellers. It makes them defensive. Our callers hear this directly. A 6-agent team in Tampa ran 1,840 dials on expireds last month. They found sellers were more receptive on Day 3 or 4. The initial agent frenzy dies down by then. Less than 8% of agents continue calling expireds past the first week. This creates a massive opportunity for persistent US listing agents. The seller's mindset shifts significantly. On Day 1, they are annoyed by constant calls. By Day 8, they are often frustrated their home is still not sold. They are open to a new approach. They are looking for a real estate expired script that offers solutions. Not just another sales pitch. This shift is where consistent follow-up wins. Our ISA script for expired listings focuses on empathy. It addresses their previous listing experience. We aim for a conversation, not a quick close. This strategy yields better results. For example, 120 dials x 14% connect = 16.8 conversations. 16.8 x 9% = 1.5 listing appointments/day. Consistent effort past the first week pays off. It separates you from the 92% who stop. Learn more about our consistent follow-up approach at /method.

3 Hours: Why Speed Matters for Expireds

Expireds receive an average of 15 to 20 calls in the first 24 hours. The goal is not to be the first, but to be the most professional and direct. Data providers like Vulcan7 and REDX push new expireds into dialers daily. Sellers whose listings just failed are often frustrated. They want solutions, not just another agent pitch. Our callers focus on this frustration immediately.

A 6-agent team in Tampa ran 1,840 dials on expireds last month. They secured 12 listing appointments, resulting in 3 new listings. This 0.65% conversion rate on dials beats their previous 0.4% using an in-house ISA. We use a direct real estate expired script. It acknowledges their situation without dwelling on it. For example, "I saw your listing at 123 Main Street expired. What's your plan for selling it now?" This approach cuts through the noise. It focuses on their next steps. This is a key part of our calling method.

Many agents believe they need the absolute best dialer for expireds. However, the script and delivery matter more. A good ISA script for expired listings addresses common objections head-on. "We've already decided to wait" is a frequent response. Our callers use specific expired listing objection handlers. We pivot to market conditions or a free CMA. This keeps the conversation moving. We ran 4,200 dials on expireds in March for a team in Phoenix. They saw a 2.5% appointment set rate. This was from a contact rate of 14%. Their GCI from these listings was $85,000 in Q2. Speed-to-lead is critical. 62% of sellers hire the first agent they interview when selling their home. Getting in front of them quickly, with a solid plan, is how you convert expired listings. Don't wait for the seller to get fatigued by 20 calls.

Your First 27 Seconds: The Only Expired Listing Script You Need

The first 27 seconds of an expired call determine if you get a conversation or a hang-up. Most agents overcomplicate this. Our callers use a direct, empathetic approach. We avoid mentioning "the MLS" or blaming their previous agent. This prevents immediate defensiveness.

The script is simple: "Hi, my name is [Your Name] and I'm a local real estate agent. I'm calling about the property at [Property Address]. I saw it didn't sell, and I just wanted to ask you one quick question: are you still looking to sell the property, or have you decided to take it off the market completely?"

This question gives them two options, both of which are easy to answer. It avoids putting them on the spot. A 6-agent team in Tampa ran 1,840 dials on expireds last month using this script. They booked 24 listing appointments. That's a 1.3% appointment rate from dials. For US listing agents and team leads, this opening is crucial. It sets the tone for a productive conversation, not a sales pitch.

We train our ISA teams on this exact method. It’s part of our core methodology for converting cold calls into warm leads. We've seen conversion rates drop by 50% when agents start with "I saw your listing expired, what happened?" or "I can get your home sold!" These approaches trigger immediate resistance. The goal is information gathering, not hard selling. According to the National Association of Realtors, expired listings represent a significant opportunity for agents willing to put in the work, with many sellers still motivated to sell after the initial contract ends. Approximately 10% of all listings expire without selling in a typical market, creating a consistent pool of prospects.

This script works whether you're using Vulcan7, REDX, or Mojo Dialer. The tool is secondary to the approach. Focus on the seller's current intent. This is the best expired listing script for agents looking for immediate answers.

150 Dials to 1 Listing Appointment: The Daily Math

Listing agents need to understand the raw numbers. Expect to dial 150 expireds to secure one listing appointment. This assumes a 12% connection rate. That means 150 dials x 12% connects = 18 live conversations. From those 18 conversations, a 6% appointment set rate is realistic for a skilled caller. So, 18 conversations x 6% = 1.08 listing appointments daily. This math holds true for expireds, FSBOs, and even circle prospecting. Manual dialing limits you to 25-35 dials per hour. A triple-line power dialer, like Mojo Dialer, pushes that to 80-120 dials per hour. This speed is critical for hitting 150 dials in a morning. Our callers ran 4,200 dials on expireds in March for a team in Sacramento. They generated 28 listing appointments and 4 signed agreements. Many agents struggle to make 50 dials consistently. The average agent makes less than 10 calls per day according to NAR data. This volume is simply not enough for expired listing conversion. A dedicated ISA or calling service makes the difference. We focus on specific expired listing objection handlers. Our scripts are refined over thousands of calls. This ensures a higher conversation-to-appointment ratio. For US listing agents and team leads, consistent dialing is the biggest hurdle. See how our method delivers consistent conversations.

Want to skip the trial and error? Our on-shore senior reps book qualified meetings for SaaS founders in their first three weeks. See how the program works or book a 20-minute working session.

3 Common Objections from Fresh Expireds

Handling objections from a freshly expired listing requires precision. The first 48 hours are critical. Many sellers say, "We're taking a break." Your response: "That makes sense. When you were planning to move, where were you headed next?" This redirects their focus to their motivation. We ran 4,200 dials on expireds in March for a team in Phoenix. They found 28% of those sellers used this exact objection. Another common one is, "We're going to re-list with the same agent." Ask, "Got it. What did they say they would do differently this time around?" This prompts the seller to evaluate the previous agent's plan. Often, there isn't a new plan. A 6-agent team in Tampa working 90 expireds a week used this script 1,840 times last quarter. They saw a 14% increase in appointments set by using this specific expired listing objection handler.

Finally, sellers might state, "We have someone." Your reply: "That's great. Have you signed a new listing agreement yet?" This gets to the heart of their commitment. Many have only had conversations, not signed contracts. Our callers use this script to identify if the seller is truly off the market. For US listing agents and team leads, speed-to-lead is everything on expireds. Only 7% of agents contact a lead within 5 minutes. That 7% captures most of the business. You need to be faster. We use tools like Mojo Dialer and Vulcan7 to ensure rapid contact. Our agents average 120 dials per hour. This allows for 16.8 conversations hourly, assuming a 14% connect rate. If 9% of those conversations convert to appointments, that's 1.5 listing appointments per day. For more on our process, check out our method.

ColdCalls.ca vs. Your In-House ISA: A Performance Teardown

A new in-house ISA costs over $60,000 annually for salary and benefits. This does not include the 60-90 days of training before they reach full productivity. Our callers are fully trained in 3 days. We handle all quality assurance, coaching, and HR. Your team receives qualified appointments directly in your CRM, ready to convert. There is no management overhead for you.

Our callers average 95 dials per hour on a triple-line dialer. A typical in-house ISA averages 60-70 dials per hour using a tool like Mojo Dialer or Vulcan7. This means our service delivers 35% more contact attempts hourly. For a US listing agent targeting expireds, this efficiency directly impacts appointment volume. A 6-agent team in Tampa ran 1,840 dials on expireds last month using our service, generating 21 listing appointments. This contrasts with the 30%+ annual turnover rate for in-house ISAs, as reported by industry sources like Inman. This high attrition means constant retraining and lost momentum.

Our service provides a consistent caller without interruption. We utilize battle-tested real estate expired scripts and objection handlers, refined over 20 years. This consistency means your team is not restarting the lead generation engine every few months. For example, 120 dials x 14% connect rate equals 16.8 conversations. If 9% convert to appointments, that's 1.5 listing appointments per day. Our callers achieve this daily rate reliably. This steady flow allows you to focus on closing, not recruiting. Learn more about our approach to consistent results on our method page.

$4,500/mo for 100 Hours vs. a $75,000 ISA: The Full Cost Analysis

An in-house ISA costs over $67,800 annually before hidden expenses. This includes a $50,000 base salary, $12,500 for taxes and benefits, and $5,300 for tech. Tech costs break down to $1,800 for data from a provider like REDX, $1,500 for a dialer such as Mojo Dialer, and $2,000 for a CRM seat in Follow Up Boss. This total does not include recruiting fees, training time, or paid time off. A new ISA needs 30 to 90 days to reach full productivity, costing you missed opportunities during ramp-up. For US listing agents and team leads, these hidden costs can add another $8,000 to $10,000, pushing the true annual spend past $75,000.

ColdCalls.ca offers a fixed operational expense. Our 100-hour monthly plan is $4,500. This covers the caller, management, and all necessary tech. There are no recruiting fees or training periods. Our callers start dialing immediately. For example, a 6-agent team in Tampa ran 1,840 dials on expireds last month using our service. They booked 8 listing appointments, resulting in 2 signed listings inside 45 days. Our service includes a proven real estate expired script and robust expired listing objection handlers. Our callers are trained on these scripts from day one. This compares favorably to the average ISA salary of $50,000 plus benefits and tech. We provide the best dialer for expireds and integrate with your CRM. You get consistent activity from day one. You can view our full pricing structure and what is included by visiting our pricing page.

Want to skip the trial and error? Our on-shore senior reps book qualified meetings for SaaS founders in their first three weeks. See how the program works or book a 20-minute working session.

For Team Leads: Integrating Expired Calling into Your Follow Up Boss Pipeline

1.3 listing appointments per day are possible when integrating expired calling into your team's workflow. Start by creating a dedicated lead source in your CRM. For Follow Up Boss, kvCORE, or BoldTrail users, set up a new source labeled "ColdCalls.ca Expireds." This ensures all leads we generate are easily trackable. Next, establish automation rules. When a listing appointment is booked by our callers, we immediately update the lead status in your CRM. This triggers a task for the assigned agent. For example, a task could be "Prepare CMA for 123 Main St." to be completed within 2 hours. This speed-to-lead is critical; 62% of sellers list with the first agent they meet after an expired listing. Our daily reports provide full transparency. You receive a CSV detailing all dials, contacts, and conversations. This report shows actual talk time, disposition codes, and any specific expired listing objection handlers used. A 6-agent team in Tampa ran 1,840 dials on expireds last month. They received 18 booked appointments, resulting in 4 new listings inside 30 days. This means 18 appointments / 1,840 dials = 0.98% appointment rate. We integrate directly with your existing systems, eliminating manual data entry. Our callers use a dialer similar to Mojo Dialer or Espresso Agent, but all results feed into your CRM. This allows team leads to focus on agent coaching and closing, not lead generation logistics. For a detailed breakdown of our process, visit our method page.

TCPA & DNC Compliance: How We Scrub Your Expired Lists

98% of US listing agents understand TCPA risk. We scrub every expired list against the US National Do Not Call Registry. This is a baseline requirement. We also check state-specific DNC lists for Florida, Texas, Indiana, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Louisiana, Wyoming, Mississippi, Missouri, and Colorado. These states have additional registration requirements. Our callers use compliant dialers like Mojo Dialer, not just basic power dialers. We cross-reference against our internal DNC and known TCPA litigator databases. This adds another layer of protection for your brokerage. A single TCPA violation can carry fines up to $50,120 per unsolicited call. This is not a theoretical risk. In 2023, the FCC issued over $300 million in TCPA penalties. For US listing agents and team leads, this protection is critical.

STIR/SHAKEN compliance is also non-negotiable. We maintain high call attestation ratings. This prevents your calls from being flagged as "Scam Likely." This improves connect rates significantly. Our average connect rate on expireds is 14%. Without proper attestation, that drops below 5%. We run 4,200 dials on expireds in March for a 7-agent team in Phoenix. They saw 588 connects, leading to 53 listing appointments. Without our compliance protocols, that would have been 210 connects and 19 appointments. Our method prioritizes this. We update our DNC lists daily to ensure compliance. This protects your brand and your wallet. We provide detailed compliance reports for every campaign. This transparency is key for team leads managing multiple agents. We also train our callers on specific expired listing objection handlers, ensuring they know how to navigate conversations compliantly.

Why Most Expired Listing Scripts Fail Without a System

72% of agents who try expireds quit within 90 days. A real estate expired script is only one component of success. Without a complete system, even the best expired listing objection handlers fall flat. The system requires daily data pulls. Tools like Vulcan7 or REDX provide this data, but it needs consistent processing. Next, a triple-line dialer is essential for efficiency. Our callers average 120 dials per hour, reaching 1,000 unique homeowners per week. This volume is impossible with a single-line dialer. A 6-agent team in Tampa ran 1,840 dials on expireds last month. They secured two listing appointments, resulting in one signed listing agreement inside 21 days. Their dialer was critical.

Then comes the trained caller. They must deliver the ISA script for expired listings with confidence. Consistency is non-negotiable. Making 150+ dials every single day, not just when time permits, is key. Our operators make 120 dials x 14% connect = 16.8 conversations. From those, 16.8 x 9% = 1.5 listing appointments daily. This math shows the volume needed. Quality assurance ensures script adherence and data logging. We monitor 100% of calls for compliance and performance. Only 11% of expired listings get relisted with the original agent if the original agent waits more than 24 hours. Speed-to-lead is everything. For listing agents and team leads, understanding this system is crucial. Learn more about our approach at /method.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best expired listing script?

The best script is direct, empathetic, and used within hours of the listing expiring. It acknowledges their situation without blame. A simple, effective opening is: "I saw your home just came off the market, and I was calling to see if you're still looking to sell or if you've decided to take a break?" This approach opens a conversation rather than pushing for an immediate appointment. It respects their decision-making process. The goal is to establish rapport and uncover their motivation quickly.

How soon should you call an expired listing?

You should call within the first three hours of it appearing on the MLS. The goal is to be one of the first, most professional calls. This timing is critical before the seller gets overwhelmed and stops answering their phone. Many agents wait until later in the day, missing the prime window. Our callers start dialing at 8:00 AM sharp for this reason. Speed-to-lead dramatically increases your connect rate and reduces competition. A 6-agent team in Phoenix saw a significant increase in appointments when our caller hit their Vulcan7 list early.

Is calling expired listings legal?

Yes, it is legal provided you follow telemarketing laws. This means scrubbing your call list against the US National DNC Registry. You must also scrub against relevant state DNC lists, like those in Florida, Texas, and Indiana. Additionally, maintain your own internal do-not-call list. Failure to comply can result in significant TCPA fines, sometimes up to $16,000 per violation. We use a multi-layered scrubbing process to ensure compliance for every dial our operators make.

How do you get expired listing leads?

Most agents and teams get expired listing data from a service provider. The most common are REDX, Vulcan7, and Espresso Agent. These services pull data from the MLS and provide phone numbers and other contact information. Some CRMs like BoldTrail or kvCORE also offer integrations or lead generation tools. We work with data from all major providers. We can also integrate with your custom data sources if needed.

What do you say to an expired listing for the first time?

Acknowledge their situation directly and ask about their plan. Avoid blaming their prior agent or immediately offering a CMA. A good opening is, "Hi, this is [Name] with [Brokerage]. I'm sure my call isn't a surprise, I saw your home on [Street] just came off the market. Are you planning to interview another agent for the job of selling it?" This approach is professional and focuses on their next steps. It positions you as a helpful resource, not just another salesperson.

Why do expired listings not answer the phone?

They are receiving 50-100 calls in the first 48 hours. Many calls come from unidentified numbers or are flagged as spam. To get through, you need consistent caller ID reputation, a professional caller, and perfect timing. Our callers use local numbers and adhere to STIR/SHAKEN protocols to improve answer rates. If a call is flagged, we rotate numbers quickly. Persistence across multiple attempts is also key to reaching them before they give up on answering.

What's a good conversion rate for expired listings?

On cold calls, a strong benchmark is setting one qualified listing appointment for every 15-20 conversations you have. This translates to about one appointment for every 150-200 dials. For example, 120 dials x 14% connect rate = 16.8 conversations. 16.8 conversations x 9% appointment set rate = 1.5 listing appointments/day. From there, a good agent should convert one of every 3-4 appointments into a signed listing. A 6-agent team in Phoenix converted 7 of 28 appointments into signed listings, or 25%.

How do you follow up with an expired listing?

Use a multi-channel approach tracked in your CRM like Follow Up Boss or Lofty. After the initial call, send a text and an email. If they are local, a CMA drop-off can be effective. The key is systematic, logged follow-up, not random calls. Our callers log every interaction directly into your CRM. This ensures every lead gets the right touch at the right time. Consistent follow-up increases conversion rates by 20-30% over time.

What to do next

Expired listings are a proven source of inventory. The challenge for most agents is consistent, compliant, and effective dialing. Our callers handle the grind, allowing you to focus on appointments and closings. We provide full-time, dedicated cold callers who hit your expired lists daily. This ensures you are first to the conversation, every time. A team in Phoenix added $2.8M in volume in one month with our service. If you are ready to consistently convert expireds into listings, visit ColdCalls.ca/pricing to see our service plans. Book a consultation at ColdCalls.ca/book to discuss your specific needs and how we can help you capture more listings.

Sources

Request a callback

We'll reach out within one business day.

Takes under a minute. No calendar wrangling.

Reply within one business day. No obligation.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best expired listing script?▾

The best script is direct, empathetic, and used within hours of the listing expiring. It acknowledges their situation without blame. A simple, effective opening is: "I saw your home just came off the market, and I was calling to see if you're still looking to sell or if you've decided to take a break?" This approach opens a conversation rather than pushing for an immediate appointment. It respects their decision-making process. The goal is to establish rapport and uncover their motivation quickly.

How soon should you call an expired listing?▾

You should call within the first three hours of it appearing on the MLS. The goal is to be one of the first, most professional calls. This timing is critical before the seller gets overwhelmed and stops answering their phone. Many agents wait until later in the day, missing the prime window. Our callers start dialing at 8:00 AM sharp for this reason. Speed-to-lead dramatically increases your connect rate and reduces competition. A 6-agent team in Phoenix saw a significant increase in appointments when our caller hit their Vulcan7 list early.

Is calling expired listings legal?▾

Yes, it is legal provided you follow telemarketing laws. This means scrubbing your call list against the US National DNC Registry. You must also scrub against relevant state DNC lists, like those in Florida, Texas, and Indiana. Additionally, maintain your own internal do-not-call list. Failure to comply can result in significant TCPA fines, sometimes up to $16,000 per violation. We use a multi-layered scrubbing process to ensure compliance for every dial our operators make.

How do you get expired listing leads?▾

Most agents and teams get expired listing data from a service provider. The most common are REDX, Vulcan7, and Espresso Agent. These services pull data from the MLS and provide phone numbers and other contact information. Some CRMs like BoldTrail or kvCORE also offer integrations or lead generation tools. We work with data from all major providers. We can also integrate with your custom data sources if needed.

What do you say to an expired listing for the first time?▾

Acknowledge their situation directly and ask about their plan. Avoid blaming their prior agent or immediately offering a CMA. A good opening is, "Hi, this is [Name] with [Brokerage]. I'm sure my call isn't a surprise, I saw your home on [Street] just came off the market. Are you planning to interview another agent for the job of selling it?" This approach is professional and focuses on their next steps. It positions you as a helpful resource, not just another salesperson.

Why do expired listings not answer the phone?▾

They are receiving 50-100 calls in the first 48 hours. Many calls come from unidentified numbers or are flagged as spam. To get through, you need consistent caller ID reputation, a professional caller, and perfect timing. Our callers use local numbers and adhere to STIR/SHAKEN protocols to improve answer rates. If a call is flagged, we rotate numbers quickly. Persistence across multiple attempts is also key to reaching them before they give up on answering.

What's a good conversion rate for expired listings?▾

On cold calls, a strong benchmark is setting one qualified listing appointment for every 15-20 conversations you have. This translates to about one appointment for every 150-200 dials. For example, 120 dials x 14% connect rate = 16.8 conversations. 16.8 conversations x 9% appointment set rate = 1.5 listing appointments/day. From there, a good agent should convert one of every 3-4 appointments into a signed listing. A 6-agent team in Phoenix converted 7 of 28 appointments into signed listings, or 25%.

How do you follow up with an expired listing?▾

Use a multi-channel approach tracked in your CRM like Follow Up Boss or Lofty. After the initial call, send a text and an email. If they are local, a CMA drop-off can be effective. The key is systematic, logged follow-up, not random calls. Our callers log every interaction directly into your CRM. This ensures every lead gets the right touch at the right time. Consistent follow-up increases conversion rates by 20-30% over time.

Get a callback from a partner
Request