Subprime auto lending

Subprime auto lender turned 14,000 aged leads into 31 held finance appointments a month

Automotive finance business following up on its own previously unworked enquiries and applications, with client-approved calling criteria.

90 days, Q2 2026

Program results

MetricBeforeAfter
Held finance appointments per month931
Contact rate on aged files2.4 percent9.6 percent
Funded deals attributed to outbound2 per month11 per month
Cost per held appointmentNot measured$182

Outreach volume and connect rates

Dial volume
6,400 dials per month across three senior on-shore callers
Connect rate
9.6 percent connect rate on leads 30 to 180 days old
Conversations
614 live conversations per month with applicants
Meetings
38 booked appointments per month, 31 held
Cost per meeting
$148 per booked appointment, $182 per held appointment

Where they started

  • Internet leads and credit applications were worked hard for five days, then abandoned, which left most of the file effectively untouched.
  • The in-house team made calls between processing live applications, so calling stopped completely during busy funding periods.
  • With a 2.4 percent contact rate and no re-attempt cadence, roughly $1.1M in annual lead spend was being written off.

What changed

  • Every record 30 to 180 days old went into a structured re-attempt cadence: six call attempts across different dayparts over 21 days, then a rest period, then a second pass.
  • Openers referenced the applicant's original enquiry and the vehicle class they applied for, never a generic financing pitch, which lifted contact-to-appointment conversion 1.9x.
  • Eleven funded deals a month were attributed to the calling program, against a per-held-appointment cost of $182 and average front-end gross above $2,300 per funded deal.

Compliance notes

  • Calls placed only to leads the lender owned and was authorized to call: internet enquiries and credit applications submitted directly to the lender. We do not buy, sell, or supply consumer data.
  • Every file scrubbed against internal suppression, national and state DNC where required, and a known-litigator list before the first dial.
  • Live human callers only. No autodialer, no prerecorded or AI voice on consumer lines.
  • Calling hours enforced at 8am to 9pm in the applicant's local time zone, with same-day opt-out logging honored across all future pulls.

We were paying for leads we stopped calling on day five. Putting a dedicated team on the aged file turned spend we had written off into our cheapest funded deals.

VP of Sales, non-prime auto lender

Questions buyers ask about this program

Can aged internet leads still convert?

Yes. In this program, leads 30 to 180 days old produced a 9.6 percent contact rate and 31 held finance appointments a month, because the original intent was real and the file had simply been underworked after day five.

Is calling aged auto leads TCPA compliant?

It is when the consumer gave the lender prior express consent by submitting the enquiry or application directly, the file is scrubbed against suppression and litigator lists, calling hours are honored, and calls are placed by live humans rather than an autodialer. Purchased third-party lists do not carry that consent and we will not call them.

Book a strategy call Subprime auto lead callingDealership lead follow-upConsumer calling compliance
Get a callback from a partner
Request